Cofactors for Omega 3 metabolism
Vitamin B6 adequacy is critical, magnesium is also needed. Excess omega 6 competes for enzymes that help us make DHA & that is a bigger issue than lack of dietary DHA. EPA seems unnecessary metabolite
This post has summary points from a 25 page pdf by Chris Masterjohn - you have to subscribe to his Substack/Masterpass to download it for free. He doesn’t have an individual price. How Essential Are the Essential Fatty Acids?
I spent two hours reading it and wrote a few summary points for myself as it helped clarify my issues.
Vitamin B6 is a critical cofactor for an enzyme needed to make the omega 3 fatty acid DHA and my apparent pyroluria causes me to need a supplement with greater than dietary amounts. I lose too much from hemoglobin breakdown along with zinc. I need both as supplements most days or I start feeling a little weird, more anxious.
Magnesium is also a cofactor of some sort and I tend to be low in that too. Anyone with inflammation can become low in magnesium or short term following alcohol excess or use of other diuretics.
Biotin is also needed.
A high sugar diet interferes with omega 3 production.
Excess omega 6 fatty acids from seed or grain oils will negatively impact DHA production as the same enzymes are used - so the greater amount of omega 6 precursors would compete and win for the enzymes catalytic spots.
If someone had a gene allele causing dysfunction in some of the enzymes then they would need a dietary source of DHA.
Pregnancy does however require more DHA for fetal cognitive development than at any other stage of life. Breast milk does or should have DHA. (The fats in breast milk largely reflect the fats in the woman’s diet.)
The pdf by Masterjohn seems to be responding to the market’s focus on omega 3 fatty acids as supplements or fish oil — and is it really that important? He goes through a LARGE number of animal studies designed to show whether fats in the diet are essential for health or not. Very refined fat free diets were created to feed to lab animals to see whether or how they got sick - and then various types of fat sources would be provided to see what helped the animals get better. And a couple human examples were included. The review of research suggests or shows that having the omega 6 fatty acid arachidonic acid in the diet seems to be more essential for health than directly having DHA in the diet.
He doesn’t mention in the pdf but arachidonic acid is the lipid used in the endocannabinoids anandamide and 2-AG - which are the THC and the CBD equivalents that we can make for ourselves if genetically normal and apparently when arachidonic acid is available.
Omega 3 fatty acid DHA also can be made into an endocannabinoid which has anti-inflammatory benefits and may help prevent autoimmune promoting Th17 and pro-inflammatory Th1 T-cells.
Abstract: “Epidemiological studies show that omega-3 fatty acid consumption is associated with improved conditions in neurodegenerative diseases such as multiple sclerosis (MS). However, the mechanism of this association is not well understood. Emerging evidence suggests that parent molecules such as docosahexaenoic acid are converted into downstream metabolites that are capable of directly modulating immune responses. In vitro, we found that docosahexaenoyl ethanolamide (DHEA), another dietary component and its epoxide metabolite, reduced the polarization of naïve T-cells toward proinflammatory Th1 and Th17 phenotypes. Furthermore, we identified that DHEA and related endocannabinoids are changing during the disease progression in mice undergoing relapse-remitting experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (RR-EAE). In addition, daily administration of DHEA to mice delayed the onset of disease, the rate of relapse, and the severity of clinical scores at relapse in RR-EAE, an animal model of MS. Collectively, these data indicate that DHEA and their downstream metabolites reduce the disease severity in the RR-EAE model of MS and can be potential dietary adjuvants to existing MS therapeutics.” (Kim, et al., 2023)
*This DHEA, docosahexaenoyl ethanolamide, is not the same DHEA that is used for hormone support once over age 35. That DHEA is called dehydroepiandrosterone.
Summary of our needs for better omega 3 metabolism:
Adequate vitamin B6, biotin and magnesium,
and some omega 6 fatty acids for arachidonic acid, but not too much to disrupt omega 3 fatty acid production. Fatty fish can help but more variety of trace minerals and fats would be found in a mixed diet with (organically reared) meats including organ meats or oysters/shellfish.
Avoid a diet high in sugar or simple carbohydrates as that also interferes with omega 3 production.
And some dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) for anyone over age 35 may be helpful for health too. As a female I use 25 mg a day, males might benefit from 75 mg a day. It helps us to build muscle tissue which is reduced as we age. It may be ‘anti-aging’ for us. *Addition - a comment shared caution regarding the dose of DHEA for men or women, not going above 10 mg/day might be safer. I should read more on this topic as new information may be available. Small doses of progesterone can be helpful for post menopausal women or men. Wild yam cream is how I use progesterone - topically. It helped reduce peri-menopausal hot flashes and irritability for me.
Random search result ~ What is the difference between DHA and DHEA and should I take them when pregnant or breast feeding? (myovaterra.com)
The amounts of omega 3 being recommended for pregnancy and lactation seem accurate. They do mention the risks of oxidized/old omega 3 supplements. Keep it refrigerated and use promptly. Fatty fish like salmon and sardines are a source and algae is being used to make a vegetarian supplement that is more similar to DHA than plant sources of omega 3 precursors. (myovaterra.com) *They are listing EPA as also beneficial which Chris Masterjohn’s pdf suggests is maybe not true for human needs.
A food safety resource for industrial food processing
A free ebook for 2023 courtesy of Food Safety Magazine. The link goes to article 3 which is about how clean a food processing line in order to remove biofilm risk -
Salmonella or other hazardous bacteria can form hard to remove biofilm in crevices or damaged areas of machinery or interior surfaces of a food processing plant. The article for non-industry readers is still interesting to show how much work goes into keeping our food supply clean (or which should occur). The article is geared towards factories or a high risk food setting like chicken processing with salmonella risk, but it would be a helpful guide for any food service business - to increase awareness of risks and provide recommended steps for cleaning. (digital.bnpengage.com/ebook-pssi-effective-sanitation-1023/fsm-article-3/)
Disclaimer: This information is being shared for educational purposes within the guidelines of Fair Use and is not intended to provide individual health guidance.
Reference List
(Kim, et al., 2023) Kim JS, Soto-Diaz K, Bingham TW, Steelman AJ, Das A. Role of omega-3 endocannabinoids in the modulation of T-cell activity in a multiple sclerosis experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) model. J Biol Chem. 2023 Feb;299(2):102886. doi: 10.1016/j.jbc.2023.102886. Epub 2023 Jan 7. PMID: 36626985; PMCID: PMC9926309. https://www.jbc.org/article/S0021-9258(23)00018-2/fulltext
Thanks, Jennifer for assiduously predigesting Chris MasterJohn's work for us. I've read him before and he gets to be exhaustively deep into the subject. And yet, anyone researching on Omega 3 before, and on DHA, knows this is a difficult subject to ever feel one has mastered. There's always more turning up from further studies.
In the last 8 years I've tried to NOT supplement to obtain a sufficient amount of parent omega 3, or of the derivatives DHA and EPA, often the major components of "fish/krill oil" capsules. This is due to the ease with which omega-3 oils oxidize, which is fully more than 3 times as quickly as omega-6 oils, which already have a horrible reputation for being in a damaging state by the time they are consumed as a "vegetable oil". I'm just afraid that capsules containing the omega-3 oils may deliver only oxidized oils which will be worse than having no omega-3 content in the capsules at all. I do believe that with intake of quite fresh fish, meats, and yes, even vegetables, an adequate level of alpha-linolenic acid may be ingested and the body may derive the DHA and EPA from that parent oil, providing, as you advise, the minerals, vitamins and enzymes are on hand to aid in the task. Our bodies really do not need massive doses of these oils. Actually, I probably get enough just from eating 2 or 3 cans of sardines each week, provided the canning process preserved the oils sufficiently.
Regarding the hormone DHEA which you briefly mention as an aside: "And some dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) for anyone over age 35 may be helpful for health too", I must mention that I had a scary exposure to this DHEA after reading some positive statements about it being just another one of the endogenously manufactured substances that appears in lower and lower quantities as we age, until it is non-existent at about the time of death from old age. From that recommendation, at about the age of 65, I began taking 25 mg/ day. After about a hear, I noticed a swelling in one breast, not normal for any male human. After a lot of research I decided it must be due to the DHEA, and commenced taking some things (progesterone and passion flower for two) and totally stopped the DHEA which I found out can be quite hormone disruptive in doses over 10 mg. I don't want your readers to be mislead by what you said without doing additional research on this DHEA. Now, Progesterone turned out to fix the problem and I stopped using it after about a year, but have also recently gone on it again due to self diagnosed high levels of estrogens from plant foods I'm fond of. Progesterone, in just 10 mg doses, seems to be quite safe for mature males, much safer than any doses of Testosterone or DHEA, but any hormone manipulation of course should be done with care or even under the care of a professional that can test and advise, such as you may do.
Thanks again for your insightful articles which I read often, and with great anticipation for additional perspectives on subjects that often are of great interest to me.
Excellent information, Nutrition Goddess! Thank you!